If something's off with your lists, work through the relevant case below.
Can't Create a List#
Free accounts can create up to 10 custom lists — if you're at the cap, delete an existing list or upgrade to PRO for unlimited. If the Create New List button is missing entirely, make sure you're logged in.
Can't Add Items#
- List is full. Free accounts cap at 100 items per list; PRO is 500. Wishlists cap at 500 regardless of plan.
- Wrong entity type. Each list holds one type — you can't add a character to an issue list.
- Already there. Each item can only appear once per list.
Can't Delete#
Your built-in Wishlist can't be deleted — it's permanent. You can make it private and empty it out if you don't want to use it.
Can't Make a List Private#
Free accounts can only make the Wishlist private. Custom lists on free are always public — upgrade to PRO for private custom lists.
List Not Showing for Others#
- Confirm the list is set to Public
- Empty lists might not surface in discovery — add items
- Your profile might be private, which hides your lists from visitors
Items Missing#
- Active filters or search terms may be hiding items
- Clear the search bar (even a single space changes results)
- Hard-refresh the page to rule out a stale display
Can't Reorder Items#
Only ranked lists support custom ordering. Unranked lists sort automatically.
Still Stuck?#
Contact support with what you were trying to do, what happened instead, and any error messages.