A key issue noted for First appearance of Charcoal. Thunderbolts #19 was published by Marvel Comics on October 1, 1998, as part of a series that began in 1997. Kurt Busiek and Stan Lee write, and art comes from Joe Rosas, Mark Bagley and Richard Horie. This 46-page issue features Moonstone, Abe Jenkins, Songbird, Klaw and Atlas, among 13 characters cataloged on VerseDB.